Homes with Lake Toxaway Frontage for Sale

MLS Number 1001023

• Residential
• Bedrooms 5
• Bathroom 10
• Acreage 1.3

The Mountain Laurel, located at 41 Chimney Point is a premier lakefront estate that epitomizes privacy, exclusive and refined craftsmanship crafted by esteemed builder John Lupoli, the home showcases old world elegance sitting on over 1.3 acres with over 300 feet of Shoreline. The home has too many features to list, but among them include plaster walls, multiple stone fireplaces, an elevator to all floors and expansive outdoor living spaces. The gourmet kitchen is equipped with custom cabinetry, a Lacanche Cote D'Or oven, brass apron and prep sinks and two walk-in pantries. In addition, a covered breezeway connects a double carport, one car garage with a game room, theater, full bath and kitchenette above. This estate offers a serene retreat with breathtaking lake and mountain views, providing an unparalleled living experience in Western North Carolina.

Listed by William D. Heinitsh of Lake Toxaway Company

MLS Number 106456

• Residential
• Bedrooms 4
• Bathroom 7
• Acreage 1.12

One of Lake Toxaway and Western North Carolina's most magnificent legacy homes, this masterfully crafted 4BR, 5.5BA estate is situated on two prime lakefront point lots with 326 feet of lake frontage on fabled Lake Toxaway. Situated very close to the Lake Toxaway Country Club, Greystone Inn, Marina, and all amenities Lake Toxaway offers, this Old World Estate offers the finest appointments including extensive stone work, large, spacious rooms, three wood burning masonry fireplaces, chef's kitchen, expansive master suite with en-suite paneled library, gracious guest suites upstairs, bonus room with full bath over a two car garage, generator, golf cart garage, extensive outdoor entertaining spaces including a covered dining porch, firepit, large stationary dock, two stall boat house, and one of the most spectacular lake and mountain views in the mountains of North Carolina. This home is a rare opportunity and a must see.

Listed by Art Fisher of Fisher Realty Highlands

MLS Number 1001104

• Residential
• Bedrooms 4
• Bathroom 4
• Acreage 2.89

Welcome to an extraordinary lakefront estate on Lake Toxaway, Western North Carolina's largest private lake, offering an unmatched blend of luxury, privacy, and future potential. Spanning 2.89 acres across two addresses-905 Cold Mountain Road and 92 Mallard Point-this rare property features two beautifully appointed homes, three additional buildable lots, multiple boat slips, and a full set of architectural plans by nationally recognized architect Dawn K. Sherry. Sherry's plans take full advantage of the property's sweeping lake and mountain views, offering a stunning vision for a custom legacy home. The waterfront main home features four bedrooms and four bathrooms, expansive lake-facing decks ideal for entertaining, and a private boathouse. Nestled just steps away is the fully renovated guest home-a charming three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath retreat with hardwood floors throughout, a spacious sunroom with panoramic lake views, a large covered porch, and an attached carport. Whether used as a guest residence, rental, or transitional space while building anew, it offers comfortable elegance and unobstructed vistas of the lake and surrounding Blue Ridge Mountains. Located in a quiet, secluded cove, the estate also boasts a large cleared lawn, a basketball court, and multiple boat slips along a stone seawall. With three additional buildable lots included, the property offers endless possibilities for expansion, investment, or creating a multi-generational compound. Buyers are drawn to Lake Toxaway for its tranquil waters, rich legacy, and exclusive atmosphere. As North Carolina's largest private lake, it spans 640 acres with 14 miles of shoreline, offering ample space for boating, fishing, and paddleboarding-reserved solely for property owners. The area's prestige is further enhanced by the Lake Toxaway Country Club, offering golf, tennis, fine dining, and more-available by invitation only. With dramatic lake and mountain views, private lake access, and limited inventory, lakefront properties like this are a rare and valuable find. Whether you're seeking a turnkey lakefront lifestyle, the foundation for a custom build, or a one-of-a-kind family retreat, this exceptional estate on Lake Toxaway delivers the best of mountain and waterfront living in one of the Southeast's most coveted lake communities.

Listed by Mitzi Rauers and John Muir of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Meadows Mountain Realty

MLS Number 1000926

• Residential
• Bedrooms 4
• Bathroom 6
• Acreage 0.68

Meticulously crafted 4 BR, 5.5 Ba custom home with level circular drive on magnificent site overlooking Lake Toxaway and Toxaway Mountain. Many custom features include a large great room with soaring ceilings and a large stone wood-burning fireplace. Well equipped chef's kitchen featuring Viking Oven/range, two dishwashers, large kitchen island for entertaining, elevator, extensive built-ins, attached garage/carport, expansive back covered porch and pavered cart path from the home to the lake, boathouse, and extensive docking make this home a legacy lake house in beautiful Lake Toxaway.

Listed by Art Fisher of Fisher Realty Highlands

MLS Number 104744

• Residential
• Bedrooms 3
• Bathroom 4
• Acreage 0.81

A RARE opportunity to have a flat lake lot and beautiful long view! This home is on a quiet road on a peaceful protected spot on the lake. 2 suites plus a 3rd bedroom and bath on the main floor. A spacious great room, kitchen and dining area that all have lake view. Easy access to roofed deck and yard from great room/dining area and master bedroom. Floor to ceiling stone fireplace and built-ins in great room. Exquisite wainscoting throughout. High ceilings and 8 foot sliding doors. Large kitchen island with room for bar stools. Large master suite has lake view and is off to one side for privacy and quiet. Also has adequate room for sitting area. Master bathroom has separate toilet/bidet room and soaking tub. Custom plantation shutters in bedroom and bath. Lots of cabinet space. Central vac system. Downstairs features a family room with built-ins and walk out to yard. Also a full bath and additional room for workout and for a bunk room. A large unfinished space that would be perfect for media room or workshop. Big laundry/pantry (drop zone) off the garage. Circular drive and 2 car garage on the .81 ac property. This is a one owner, custom built home designed by the owner. Split zone HVAC replaced in 2024. Water filtration system and water softener. According to floor plans HLA is approx. 4130 sq.ft. (2718 approx. on main floor).

Listed by Kathryn Balistreri of Balistreri Realty

MLS Number 1000905

• Residential
• Bedrooms 3
• Bathroom 3
• Acreage 1.24

Located in a tranquil cove on Island Point Road, this three bedroom, three bath lakefront home offers the perfect mountain retreat. Situated on a combined double lot totaling 1.24 acres, the property features over 150 feet of shoreline and a private dock ideal for kayaking, paddleboarding, swimming, or simply enjoying the water. A large covered porch offers a peaceful setting with views of the gently sloping yard, providing ample space for outdoor recreation. Offered furnished with few exceptions, this remarkable property is an ideal turnkey getaway.

Listed by William D. Heinitsh of Lake Toxaway Company

MLS Number 106458

• Residential
• Bedrooms 3
• Bathroom 5
• Acreage 3.05

Discover a one-of-a-kind retreat in the heart of Lake Toxaway Estates, where rustic charm meets refined luxury. Situated on over 3 private acres, this estate-like property blends timeless design with modern comforts-all with exclusive access to Lake Toxaway. Step inside the main home to find an open, light-filled floor plan, where a double-sided stone fireplace anchors the spacious living and dining areas. The upscale kitchen is outfitted with high-end finishes and offers a seamless flow to the sunlit dining area, which overlooks the manicured lawn and lake beyond. The private primary suite is a true sanctuary, featuring its own fireplace, sitting area, and a private porch-perfect for quiet mornings or evening sunsets. Each guest suite includes an en-suite bath, ensuring comfort and privacy. The finished lower level adds exceptional flexibility, offering a second kitchenette, bonus room, full bath, and laundry space. Step outside and be transported by the presence of a beautifully preserved antique cabin, complete with a kitchen, full bath, and wood-burning fireplace. Whether used as a guest cottage or private escape, it adds a rare, storybook touch to the property. This is more than a home -it's a home of distinction, offering boulder-accented landscaping, mountain and lake views. A true gem for those seeking rustic elegance in a pristine mountain setting.

Listed by Amanda Jennings Gravley of Fisher Realty Sapphire/Toxaway

MLS Number 106342

• Residential
• Bedrooms 4
• Bathroom 7
• Acreage 0.77

One of a kind 4 BR, 6.5 BA lakefront home with a magical private setting overlooking Lake Toxaway. This spacious home features hardwood floors, two kitchens, four bedroom suites, cathedral ceilings, covered porch overlooking the lake. Large stone patio/terrace adjoining the water, separate pool house with heated indoor pool. This home has exceptional rental history.

Listed by Art Fisher of Fisher Realty Highlands

MLS Number 1001174

• Condo Residential
• Bedrooms 3
• Bathroom 3
• Acreage 0.03

Just 26 paces to the croquet pitch, 52 to Court 1, a breezy 58-second golf cart ride to the first tee and you're half way to heaven! This upper end Country Club Village condominium is in the heart of it all with two side balconies looking in two directions. With sweeping views of Lake Toxaway and Panthertown Mountain, this 3BR/3BA retreat features vaulted ceilings in both the great room and primary suite, stunning hardwood floors, and a cozy wood-burning fireplace. Enjoy a beautifully landscaped setting, a sparkling pool, and your own deeded boat slip at the marina. One covered parking space is included. Lakeside living at its best. Membership to Lake Toxaway Country Club is based upon availability and application.

Listed by Fulmer Freeman of Lake Toxaway Company

MLS Number 1001412

• Residential
• Bedrooms 2
• Bathroom 4
• Acreage 0.29

Immaculate lakefront cottage on flat lot with stunning view of Lake Toxaway and Toxaway Mountain, this two bedroom, four bath home features a large bunk room, new roof, flooring, kitchen appliances, HVAC, decking, lighting, sauna, dedicated parking and dock space. With it's own flat lakefront lot, this home has a magnificent back yard with flat flagstone path, privacy fence, and beautiful outdoor seating area and is the perfect vacation getaway with one of the finest views on Lake Toxaway.

Listed by Art Fisher of Fisher Realty Highlands